By Reuters
Many doctors and other health care workers require that women have pelvic exams before they can get prescriptions for birth control pills, despite guidelines saying that the step is unnecessary, a new study finds.
Drinking glasses depicting comic book and movie characters exceed federal limits for lead in children’s products by up to 1,000 times, according to laboratory tests.
An even higher percentage — 44 percent — said they “usually” required one, according to findings published in the journal Obstetrics & Gynecology.
The number of practitioners requiring a pelvic exam is disappointingly high, researchers say, considering the fact that the World Health Organization and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) advise that birth control pills can safely be prescribed without the exam.
Unnecessary hurdle
The key problem with mandatory pelvic exams is that it puts up an unnecessary hurdle to women seeking effective birth control, according to Sawaya and his colleagues at the University of California, San Francisco.
Women have to wait until their provider can fit the exam into his or her schedule; some may be turned off by the requirement altogether and opt for less-reliable forms of contraception, like condoms.
“In my view, we should have as few barriers as possible to women trying to get effective birth control,” Sawaya said.
Pelvic exams should not be linked to oral contraception in a mandated fashion.
There is no established medical need for women to have the exam before receiving a prescription for birth control pills, Sawaya said. It’s just that, traditionally, pelvic exams have been coupled with contraceptive prescriptions; in many cases, it may have simply been convenient for women to have a pelvic exam as part of their routine healthcare at the same time they were seeking a birth-control prescription.
“The two just became linked,” Kaunitz agreed. But while there is nothing wrong with that, he said, “women also deserve the option of un-linking those two services.”
Nurses least likely to require exams
Advanced-practice nurses specializing in women’s health were the least likely to require a pelvic exam, with 16 percent saying they always did so. In contrast, nurses specializing in family medicine were more likely than all other providers to always require a pelvic exam; 45 percent said they did.
The reasons for the high rates are not clear from the study. But simple tradition could be at work, according to both Sawaya and Kaunitz. “I think old habits die hard,” Kaunitz said.
It’s also possible that some doctors require a pelvic exam in order to get the insurance reimbursement, Sawaya and his colleagues note in their report.
Medicare pays doctors about $75 for a screening pelvic exam and, depending on geography, private insurers may pay more. Contraceptive counseling, on the other hand, may not always fall into a clearly defined reimbursement category, the authors note.
“In the absence of adequate financial incentives for contraceptive counseling as an important clinical activity in its own right,” the researchers write, “providers are incentivized to conduct a physical exam with a well-reimbursed billing code.
Exams raise risks of more unnecessary tests
Along with added costs, unneeded pelvic exams also open women up to the possibility of having an abnormal finding that, upon further testing, turns out to be nothing. “Any (test) we do with an asymptomatic person has a chance of resulting in a false-positive,” Sawaya pointed out.
As for how often women should have a routine pelvic exam in the absence of any problems, there is no specific guideline. There are guidelines, however, for how often women should get a Pap test to screen for cervical cancer, which is often done in conjunction with a pelvic exam.
According to ACOG, women should begin having Pap tests at age 21, with screening repeated every two years until age 30. Women age 30 and older who have had three consecutive negative Pap tests can be screened every three years.
For women who are only seeking a birth control prescription and are told they need to schedule a pelvic exam, Sawaya suggested they ask their provider why the exam is necessary.
But he said the real message of the survey results is for practitioners, who, based on these findings, need better awareness of current guidelines on birth control prescription.
Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters. Click for restrictions.
NotableM's Blog 
Discuss: Women seeking birth control get unneeded pelvic exams
3 total comments
A third of providers always require tests, raising costs, hurdles to contraception
Most active discussions